Catit vs PetSafe Fountain: Which Should You Buy? (2026)
Catit Flower Fountain vs PetSafe Drinkwell: capacity, flow, filters and who should buy which, plus a stainless third option. Check current prices.

Quick answer: Buy the Catit LED Flower Fountain (3 L) if you want a compact, 3-liter starter fountain with three flow settings and a water-level window. Buy the PetSafe Drinkwell Original if you want PetSafe’s free-falling stream and a smaller 50 oz bowl. Need more capacity or stainless steel? The PetSafe Drinkwell Stainless 360 holds 128 oz.
We have not tested these fountains in our home. The specs below come from Catit’s Flower Fountain page and PetSafe’s official product and support pages, checked on November 18, 2026. Prices change; check the current price on each listing.
We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.
Key takeaways
- Catit Flower Fountain: 3 L (100 fl oz), three flow settings, Triple Action filter, water-level window, BPA-free plastic, 8.3 × 8.3 × 7.3 in, per Catit.
- PetSafe Drinkwell Original: 50 oz, adjustable free-falling stream, carbon filter, receiving ramp, BPA-free, top-shelf dishwasher safe, per PetSafe.
- Where PetSafe wins: the waterfall-style stream and a dishwasher-safe bowl in a smaller footprint.
- Where Catit wins: about twice the water, three distinct flow modes, and a window so you can see when it is time to refill.
- Neither? The PetSafe Drinkwell Stainless 360 is the higher-capacity stainless option PetSafe lists for multi-pet homes.
Catit vs PetSafe Fountain at a Glance
| Catit LED Flower Fountain (3 L) | PetSafe Drinkwell Original | PetSafe Drinkwell Stainless 360 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Official capacity | 3 L / 100 fl oz | 50 oz | 128 oz (1 gallon) |
| Flow | 3 settings (gentle, bubbling top, or calm streams) | Adjustable free-falling stream | 1–5 stream attachments, adjustable flow |
| Filter | Catit Triple Action Filter | Replaceable carbon filter plus pre-filter | Carbon filter and foam filter |
| Material | BPA-free plastic | BPA-free plastic | Stainless steel bowl and tower |
| Cleaning note | Follow the Catit manual | PetSafe: top-shelf dishwasher safe | PetSafe: top-rack dishwasher safe; handwash the pump |
| Best starting point | One or two cats, or picky drinkers who want a choice of flow | A single cat that prefers a falling stream | Multi-pet homes that want more water and stainless steel |
Always check the current price. Filters are the recurring cost on every model.
Capacity and Refills
Catit lists the Flower Fountain at 3 liters (100 fl oz) in a compact 8.3 × 8.3 × 7.3 in body that weighs 1.32 lb. PetSafe lists the Drinkwell Original at 50 oz, aimed at cats and small dogs. If you have two cats, or you forget mid-week refills, the Catit reservoir is the more practical of the two classics.
The Stainless 360 jumps to 128 oz, with 14.3 × 14.3 × 9.3 in dimensions on PetSafe’s page. That is the better match when several pets share one fountain. It is also larger and will not disappear into a tight corner the way the Flower Fountain can.
Flow, Noise and Picky Drinkers
Catit says the Flower Fountain can be set three ways: a gentle flow, a bubbling top, or calm streams, so you can match a fussy drinker. PetSafe’s Original uses a free-falling stream (its support page describes a 5-inch fall) and a receiving ramp meant to cut splash. The Stainless 360 goes further: five spout attachments and a twistable top to change stream strength.
We cannot honestly rate noise without a test. What you can do is set the flow low at first, place the fountain where you will hear a dry pump, and keep a bowl down for the first week. Our cat water bowl vs fountain guide covers when a bowl is still enough.
Filters, Materials and Cleaning
Catit says only filtered water is pushed to the surface, through a Triple Action Filter that it describes as softening water and reducing odors, impurities, hair and debris. PetSafe’s Original uses a replaceable activated carbon filter and a pre-filter; the Stainless 360 adds a foam filter for hair and debris.
On materials, the two starter fountains are BPA-free plastic. Some cats do better with stainless or ceramic at the drinking surface; PetSafe even notes in the Original manual that some animals are sensitive to plastic bowls. If that is your issue, skip both plastic models and look at the Stainless 360 or the stainless cordless picks in best cat water fountains.
PetSafe states the Original is top-shelf dishwasher safe and the Stainless 360 is top-rack dishwasher safe, with the pump washed by hand. Take the maker’s pump instructions seriously: a pump that runs dry will fail.
Where Each One Wins
Catit Flower Fountain wins on capacity, flow variety, and the water-level window. It is the better default for most one- or two-cat homes that want a compact plastic fountain.
PetSafe Drinkwell Original wins if your cat is clearly drawn to a falling stream, you want a smaller volume, and dishwasher-safe parts matter to you.
The Stainless 360 wins when you have several pets, you want stainless steel, or you want to drink from any side of an open bowl. It is the “neither of the two classics” option, not a like-for-like swap for the 50 oz Original.
Get the indoor cat checklist
A free setup checklist, plus occasional notes when useful cat gear actually drops in price.
By subscribing you agree to receive emails from Paw & Sage. Double opt-in, unsubscribe anytime. See our privacy policy.
Who Should Buy Which
| If you… | Start with |
|---|---|
| Want a compact 3 L fountain with three flow modes | Catit LED Flower Fountain (3 L) |
| Want PetSafe’s free-falling stream in a smaller bowl | PetSafe Drinkwell Original |
| Have several pets, or prefer stainless steel | PetSafe Drinkwell Stainless 360 |
| Still need to decide if a fountain is worth it | Cat water bowl vs fountain |
| Need placement rules | Where to put a cat water fountain |
How We Compared
This page uses Catit’s Flower Fountain specifications, PetSafe’s Drinkwell Original support page and manual details, and PetSafe’s Stainless 360 product page, all checked on November 18, 2026. Amazon listings were verified by title. We did not run a hands-on test. The method is on how we pick. For more side-by-side guides, see Compare.
If you are shopping this month, use the Black Friday cat deals hub to judge a discount, and confirm the return window on the listing. Fountains are usually easier to return than opened food or treats, but always check the product page.
Get our free indoor cat enrichment checklist
Plus seasonal picks and deals worth knowing about. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
By subscribing you agree to receive emails from Paw & Sage. Double opt-in, unsubscribe anytime. See our privacy policy.
Sources
This article cites 4 sources in the text. They are linked below.
- Catit Flower Fountain (Catit)
- Drinkwell Original Fountain (PetSafe)
- Drinkwell Stainless Steel Multi-Pet Fountain (PetSafe)
- Feline Environmental Needs (Ohio State University Indoor Pet Initiative)
Common questions
Is the Catit Flower Fountain better than a PetSafe Drinkwell?
It depends on the job. Catit's official Flower Fountain holds 3 liters (100 fl oz) and offers three flow settings plus a Triple Action filter and a water-level window. The PetSafe Drinkwell Original holds 50 oz and uses a free-falling stream, a carbon filter, and a receiving ramp. Pick Catit for capacity and flow choice; pick the Original Drinkwell if you want that waterfall-style stream in a smaller bowl.
Which fountain is better for multiple cats?
Catit's 3-liter Flower Fountain holds about twice as much water as the 50 oz Drinkwell Original, so it needs fewer refills in a two-cat home. For still more capacity and stainless steel, PetSafe's Drinkwell Stainless 360 Multi-Pet Fountain is listed at 128 oz (1 gallon) with 360-degree access and one to five stream attachments.
Are Catit and PetSafe fountains dishwasher safe?
PetSafe says the Drinkwell Original is BPA-free and top-shelf dishwasher safe, and it says the Stainless 360 is top-rack dishwasher safe with the pump handwashed separately. Catit's Flower Fountain page highlights BPA-free plastic and the Triple Action filter; follow the Catit manual for washing the pump and plastic parts.
Will a fountain make a cat drink more water?
Many cats prefer moving water, which is why fountains are a standard hydration tool. A fountain is not a guarantee. Keep at least one bowl down while you introduce it, and talk to a vet if drinking, urination or appetite changes suddenly.
Where should I put a cat water fountain?
Usually away from the litter box and not right beside the food bowl. Our placement guide covers the details. Check the water level often so the pump never runs dry.
Did Paw & Sage test these fountains?
No. This comparison uses official Catit and PetSafe specifications and verified Amazon listings. We have not run a hands-on test. See how we pick products.